CookinCityRecipes & Articles For Better Cooking At Home

Strawberry Ice Cream

A winner recipe for this delicious ice cream!

Quick answerMakes 8 servings, ready in 5 hours, Italian cuisine.
By Jaron Kimhi··👁 361 views
Strawberry Ice Cream
Nothing is more innocent than strawberry ice cream, right? It's just strawberries with milk and there you go — a perfect strawberry ice cream. I thought so too, but it's a bit more complicated than that. In fact, nailing the right proportions of cream versus fruit is a hard task. Strawberries are high in water, and it's hard to get a good ice cream consistency that won't get completely crystallized in the freezer over time. The standard ice cream guidelines are constantly changing, and it's important to evaluate (and experiment with) various proportions to get to the desired consistency.

A few insights for a great strawberry ice cream

  • Use the best strawberries. This rule applies to every ice cream or sorbet, but it's actually crucial for this one — you really want a sweet, strong flavor here, not a dull, boring one. I often ask myself if the ice cream is even made from real strawberries.
Strawberry Ice Cream
  • Go for a light-body ice cream. Trying to make it with a rich base will give you a tender scoop easily, but it'll result in a mild strawberry taste. For this flavor, I actually prefer strawberry sorbet, so convincing me to skip the egg yolks was easy.
  • Add fresh chunks of strawberries soaked in alcohol. The benefits of sugar and alcohol in ice cream — reducing freezing point and melting temperature — are well known.
Strawberry Ice Cream The recipe below was adapted from Serious Eats — they nailed the right proportions of fat versus fresh fruit and got a great result. My modifications were reducing the sugar and replacing some of the half-and-half with milk and heavy cream. I've tried different strawberry ice creams, and I have to say each recipe has its advantages. It also depends a lot on personal taste. But a good ice cream is just a good ice cream — if you can pull off a strong fruit flavor with a solid consistency, you've done a good job. Strawberry Ice Cream  

Method

  1. 1

    Making the alcohol strawberry mix· 5 minutes

    In a small bowl, hull about 1 cup of strawberries, cut into small pieces, add the alcohol, half a cup of sugar and squash the mixture lightly to release the fruits liquids. Set aside for a few hours.

    Strawberry Ice CreamStrawberry Ice Cream
  2. 2

    puree the strawberries· 5 minutes

    Place the remaining strawberries in a blender and puree until smooth. Strain the strawberry juice keeping fibers and seeds out. Keep 2 cups of strawberry juice, if there is excess juice use for the next ice cream (it's possible to freeze as well).

    Strawberry Ice CreamStrawberry Ice CreamStrawberry Ice Cream
  3. 3

    mixing the ice cream base· 5 minutes

    In a medium bowl, mix the strawberry puree with the heavy cream, milk, corn syrup, remaining 1/2 cup of sugar, salt and lemon juice. Place in the fridge for few hours preferably overnight.

    Strawberry Ice Cream
  4. 4

    churn the ice cream

    Strain the liquids of the strawberry chunks (reserve the syrup for a daiquiri) Churn the ice cream according to manufacturer instructions. 5 minutes before the end of churning add the strawberry chunks. Place in an airtight container and freeze.

    Strawberry Ice CreamStrawberry Ice CreamStrawberry Ice Cream
Recipe by

Jaron Kimhi

Jaron Kimhi — self-taught home cook from Tel Aviv, writing and cooking every recipe on this site himself. 20+ years of tinkering in the kitchen, leaning toward slow cooking, classic technique, and honest ingredients.

More recipes by Jaron →

Questions & answers

Can I swap the dark rum for something non-alcoholic?
The rum does two things here — it flavors the macerated strawberries and keeps those chunks from freezing rock-solid. You can skip it, but your strawberry chunks will be icier in the final scoop.
Do I really need an ice cream maker?
This recipe is built around churning, so yes — you need one. Follow your machine's manufacturer instructions and add the strawberry chunks 5 minutes before it's done.
Can I use frozen strawberries instead of fresh?
The recipe calls for fresh strawberries only, so stick with those — you need them to release natural juice when macerated and to puree cleanly.
What do I do with the leftover strawberry juice and the rum syrup?
Freeze any extra strawberry juice for your next batch. Pour the strained rum syrup into a daiquiri — Jaron literally built that into the recipe.
How far ahead can I make this?
Chill the ice cream base overnight before churning — that's actually the recommended move. Just make sure it's in the fridge, then churn when you're ready.

Nutrition per serving

100g
Serving size
110
Calories
4.3g
Total Fat
2.6g
Saturated
17mg
Cholesterol
35mg
Sodium