CookinCityRecipes & Articles For Better Cooking At Home

Soft Polenta with Mushroom Ragu

Tender Polenta porridge with oozy earthy mushroom ragu

Quick answerMakes 4 servings, ready in 1 hour 10 minutes, Italian cuisine.
By Jaron Kimhi··👁 423 views
polenta with Mushroom Ragu
I just love polenta with mushroom ragu on cold winter nights. It warms me up and I get that feeling of home food, which I can never get enough of. I discussed making polenta in the past and always emphasized that it's not such a big deal as traditional recipes claim. You really don't have to stir the polenta constantly — it makes no difference at all. All you need to remember to make a good creamy soft polenta is a good ratio between water and corn grits. That's what makes the difference between a dry polenta and a good corn porridge, almost soupy in texture.

Polenta with Mushroom Ragu - the concept

So, we agreed (I hope) that polenta is not such a heavy task as some recipes make it out to be, which leaves us with two spare hands to make a great complementary side dish to go with it — a hearty mushroom ragu. Mushroom ragu fits like a glove on polenta. It's a heavy mushroom sauce, almost meaty in texture and flavor — gooey and full of earthy aroma that complements the natural corn flavors without overpowering them.

The mushrooms

I like to use a variety of mushrooms. I add whatever's in season and fresh, plus dried porcini. In this recipe, I added a whole bunch of different mushrooms: dried porcini, fresh cremini, portobello, enoki, and button mushrooms.

Each mushroom has its own unique texture and distinct taste, and adding them together creates a wonderful mushroom stew with some strong earthy flavors.

polenta with Mushroom Ragu

Polenta with Mushroom Ragu - timing is everything

When making polenta with mushroom ragu, I allow about 1 hour to complete both and do them simultaneously so they're ready together. They must be served hot. I start with the polenta — add it to the pot with cold water and turn on the heat. It takes about 5 minutes before the water reaches simmering point. Meanwhile, I set another pan for the mushroom ragu, add all the ingredients, and set it on low heat for slow cooking. Mushroom ragu and polenta can be paired in many polenta textures — fried/roasted polenta (after cooling the polenta in the fridge, you can fry/roast it in small bites) or "polenta omelet" as I've cooked in the past (it's just a butter-fried soft polenta — the omelet texture forms from laying the thin layer on the pan). polenta with Mushroom Ragu  

Method

  1. 1

    Making the Polenta· 1 hour

    In a medium sauce pan or big Iron skillet set on high heat, pour the water, salt and polenta. Bring the water into a simmer and reduce heat into low. Occasionally stir the polenta preventing it from forming lumps. When polenta starts to thicken and break from the sides of the pan (after about 45-50 minutes) remove from heat, add butter, olive oil and parmesan and stir until fully incorporated.

    polentapolentapolentapolenta
  2. 2

    making the mushroom ragu· 1 hour

    While the polenta is cooking set an iron skillet on high heat. Add the butter, when its fully melted add the onions, cook for 3 more minutes and add the fresh mushrooms. Cook the mushrooms on high heat for about 7-10 minutes until the mushrooms mix lose most of their fluids. Pour the olive oil and cook for 2 more minutes, season with salt and pepper. Add the Porcini mushrooms with the water they were soaked in and cook for 2 more minutes. Pour the white wine and cook for another 2 minutes. Reduce heat to medium-low and let fluids evaporate. Adding water is optional, depending on the amount of fluids you want in the ragu, if you see the ragu is dry go ahead and add some water.

    polenta with Mushroom Ragupolenta with Mushroom Ragupolenta with Mushroom Ragupolenta with Mushroom Ragupolenta with Mushroom Ragu
  3. 3

    plating and serving

    Place a big portion of the polenta in a deep plate. Add a few spoons of the mushroom ragu on the polenta. Sprinkle with olive oil and serve.

    polenta with Mushroom Ragu
Recipe by

Jaron Kimhi

Jaron Kimhi — self-taught home cook from Tel Aviv, writing and cooking every recipe on this site himself. 20+ years of tinkering in the kitchen, leaning toward slow cooking, classic technique, and honest ingredients.

More recipes by Jaron →

Questions & answers

Can I use a different type of polenta?
The recipe just calls for plain polenta — instant or quick-cook varieties will thicken way faster than the 45–50 minutes listed, so stick with traditional coarse polenta for the right texture.
My ragu looks too dry — what do I do?
Just splash in some of that optional ½ cup of water and stir it through — the recipe builds this in exactly for that reason.
Can I swap the white wine for something non-alcoholic?
The recipe doesn't offer a swap, but since the wine cooks down for only 2 minutes, extra mushroom soaking liquid would be your closest bet — just keep the quantity the same.
Do I need all four types of mushrooms?
Nope, the recipe lists Cremini, Portobello, Enoki, and Button as a mix — use whatever combo gets you to the 3 pounds total, just make sure you've also got the dried Porcini separately since those add a different depth.
Can I make the ragu and polenta at the same time?
Yes — that's literally how the recipe is written, start the polenta first since it takes 45–50 minutes, then kick off the ragu while it cooks.

Nutrition per serving

164
Calories
8.2g
Total Fat
1.8g
Saturated
12mg
Cholesterol
570mg
Sodium
32g
Carbohydrates